Interactive webcast player

Audit & Governance Committee
Tuesday, 10th November 2026 at 7:00pm

 
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
Share this agenda point
  1. Laura Kirman
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
Share this agenda point
Share this agenda point
Share this agenda point
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Martin Morris
  2. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  3. Cllr Martin Morris
  4. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  5. Owen Sparks
  6. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  7. Owen Sparks
  8. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
Share this agenda point
  1. Owen Sparks
  2. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  3. Cllr Michael Owen
  4. Owen Sparks
  5. Cllr Michael Owen
  6. Owen Sparks
  7. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  8. Owen Sparks
  9. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  10. Cllr Michael Owen
  11. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  12. Owen Sparks
  13. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  14. Owen Sparks
  15. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  16. Cllr Martin Morris
  17. Owen Sparks
  18. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  19. Cllr Martin Morris
  20. Owen Sparks
  21. Cllr Martin Morris
  22. Owen Sparks
  23. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  24. Cllr Michael Owen
  25. Owen Sparks
  26. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  27. Cllr Mandy George
  28. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  29. Owen Sparks
  30. Cllr Mandy George
  31. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  32. Owen Sparks
  33. Cllr Mandy George
  34. Owen Sparks
  35. Cllr Paul Kelleher
  36. Owen Sparks
  37. Cllr Martin Morris
  38. Owen Sparks
  39. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  40. Cllr Martin Morris
  41. Owen Sparks
  42. Cllr Martin Morris
  43. Cllr Michael Owen
  44. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  45. Owen Sparks
  46. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
Share this agenda point
  1. Sarah Marsh
  2. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  3. Cllr Paul Kelleher
  4. Sarah Marsh
  5. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  6. Cllr Paul Kelleher
  7. Sarah Marsh
  8. Cllr Martin Morris
  9. Owen Sparks
  10. Cllr Martin Morris
  11. Owen Sparks
  12. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
Share this agenda point
  1. Owen Sparks
  2. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  3. Cllr Michael Owen
  4. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  5. Owen Sparks
  6. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  7. Sissel Heiberg
  8. Owen Sparks
  9. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  10. Cllr Martin Morris
  11. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  12. Sarah Marsh
  13. Cllr Martin Morris
  14. Sarah Marsh
  15. Owen Sparks
  16. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  17. Owen Sparks
  18. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
  19. Owen Sparks
  20. Cllr Jon Whitehouse
Share this agenda point
Share this agenda point
  1. Webcast Finished

1 Webcasting Introduction

Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:00:00
to our meeting of the Audit and Governance Committee,
particularly those for joining us for the first time.
Let me just read the webcasting announcement,
and I'd like to remind everyone
that this meeting will be filmed live and recorded
and uploaded to the internet
and capable of renewed viewing, repeated viewing.
So by participating, you can send to being filmed
and the possible use of those images and recordings.
Please turn on your microphones before speaking and turn them off when you have finished.
OK, do we have any apologies for absence?
Laura Kirman - 0:00:41
We received apologies for absence from Councillor Heather and from Heather Neill, the Court's

2 Apologies for Absence

new member.
Thanks very much.
Any declarations of interest?

3 Declarations of Interest

Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:00:46
Nope.

4 Minutes

Are people happy that the minutes on pages 4 to 7 are an accurate record?
I see nods.
Thanks very much.

5 Matters Arising

I don't think there's any matters arising because they come up later, but I'll just
cheque.
Nope.
Okay.

6 Audit & Governance Committee - Work Programme

So we can move on to the work programme, which is on page 8.
You'll see it covers the September.
It covers the June meeting, but not the September meeting, so it doesn't include the Cuffa Dexter
two items we agreed at the last meeting,
that there'll be an item on QALYST at the next meeting
picking up on the corporate governance review
that's been going on and as agreed,
we'll schedule the look at AI and fit that around
the internal audit exercise that is going on
to the use of AI into the council.
So that'll be updated after the meeting
and I think circulating the minutes.
Yeah, thanks.
Anything else on the work plan?
Yeah, you're...
Oh, yeah.
And we've been asked if we can change the date in February 2027
because of a clash.
So the proposed alternative date,
instead of Monday the 15th of February,
is Wednesday the 17th of February.
Does that cause any issues for members?
OK, well let's note the change of date then.
Sorry about that.
Anything else on the work plan?
Councillor Morris.
Cllr Martin Morris - 0:02:36
You mentioned there was something coming up on QALYST, but that was about a review of
the governance of the subsidiary.
There is quite a long ONS meeting about Qalis and a lot of discussion about it.
I was wondering if we could have, I don't know whether we are allowed to add things
to the work programme now, but I would like to see a clear plan from EFDC about how they
plan to bring Qalis into a sustainable financial situation, given that it has substantial borrowings
and repayments are being deferred and so on.
I mean, I think we should see a clear plan at this point
as to how this is going to be managed
so we can all understand what the impact is going to be
and we can make sure that the process is being properly handled.
Yeah, I mean, that's something that comes up on the Treasury management
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:03:30
and risk management, among other things that we look at.
We don't want to overlap with what
the budget process and the Audit and Scrutiny Committee are doing, but I think there are
some discussions about setting up some sort of working group or looking at where...
You've got a Venn diagram of what the Audit Committee looks at and what the Audit and
Scrutiny looks at and what the overlap bit in the middle is, a working group that covers
that and involves members from both committees.
I mean, I would say audit and the overview and scrutiny, first of all, looking at that
Cllr Martin Morris - 0:04:08
plan and agreeing that it is the right plan and then it comes to us to see whether it
is being done.
Overview and scrutiny will say whether we are doing the right thing on that plan and
we will say whether we think they have done it the right way.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:04:22
Yes, I mean, obviously overview and scrutiny has got the policy grief and we have got more
of the process grief, if that makes sense to members.
But I don't know if Mr Sparks will pick up on some of the discussions which have been
happening.
So I think there's probably two things there.
Owen Sparks - 0:04:36
One, obviously after JOB's committee, as you sort of said, Chair, it's making sure that
that scoping is done and that is approved going forward.
I think that will be done obviously between the two committees to make sure that the overlaps
are managed and it covers what members want it to cover.
I think the other thing is we will be doing a specific report on financial planning around
qualities that will go to cabinet and obviously that can go in a bunch of places as is required
and that will be to fit into the MGFP and what assumptions need to be made as part of
that going into the budget setting process.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:05:15
Yeah, and clearly that's an important part of what we look at in terms of the risk management
and in terms of the Council's financial processes.
is what's the timescale for that?
Owen Sparks - 0:05:26
Well hopefully around December time,
again it's got time to fit into the February budget.
Right, and that does fit with when we're looking at QALYSS
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:05:33
at our new year meeting as well by the sounds of it.
Okay, so if we note that down as well.
Anything else on the work plan?

7 Treasury Management Quarter 2 Report

Right, okay, so we can move on to the Treasury Management Quarter 2 report, which I think
Mrs Fox is going to introduce.
Thank you, Chair.
Owen Sparks - 0:06:00
This report provides the normal quarterly update on the capital and Treasury management
position for Quarter 2, so the first six months of this financial year.
The Treasury activity continues to be compliant with both the approved Treasury Management
strategy and the CIPFAA Treasury Management Code.
And all the relevant Treasury and financial indicators
have been complied with during the quarter.
So the Council had 277 .5 million pounds
of external borrowing at the end of September,
which is slightly lower than at the start of the year.
There has been some additional borrowing
to support Council's wider capital programme
and the completion of the existing quality developments.
And this has been offset by some planned repayments
existing general fund debt, that's resulting in a small reduction.
So the Council step remains comfortably within the approved operational and all
boundary and authorised limits. And the borrowing has a weighted average interest rate of 3 .5%,
and an average maturity of around 10 .6 years, which provides that certainty of financing
costs over sort of the medium term, especially with the relatively high borrowing costs at the moment.
So Council held 19 .7 million pounds of Treasury investments at the end of the quarter and
members will know that it's to provide liquidity, so we're giving our obligations to a full
due and we have a target of 15 million pounds, so that's being maintained.
In relation to QANIS and other service investments, we have approximately 60 .8 million pounds
outstanding, which principally provides asset purchase loans, working capital and development
loans and lending during the year has been £3 .5 million additional to Qols.
And additional to that is the £13 million loan for the Qols commercial investments,
that's for the out of town investments as well.
The forecast capital loans requirement in the year is £368 .5 million.
There's a little bit lower than the budget estimate and that really reflects assumed
slippage on the capital programme within the HRA.
So from a Treasury perspective, the council continues to operate within a challenging
and uncertain economic environment.
The bank rate had remained at 3 .75%.
Obviously that's now gone up.
And inflationary pressures, energy prices and higher yield yields are affecting our
costs of borrowing which remain relatively high
compared to previous years.
And these factors can be monitored as we develop
the MGFP and the budget moving forward into next year.
But it is still quite challenging
and quite expensive time to borrow money
in the capital markets at the moment.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:08:57
Okay, thanks very much.
Yeah, I mean, you talk about the increased cost of borrowing
is one of the figures I thought was most striking
in the report was the local indicator on page 30, the portion on the net revenue screen,
which is financing costs, which is at 10 % this year, and then goes up to 15 % over the
next four years or so, which is a sobering thought.
Okay, so lots in there.
People are familiar with the structure of the report now, I expect, but any questions
or points and numbers I wanted to pick up on.
Councillor Owen.
Cllr Michael Owen - 0:09:38
On the QALIS loan, we gave them a payment holiday,
whatever you want to call it.
Whose decision is that?
Owen Sparks - 0:09:47
That's delegated to myself under the French regulations.
That's in consultation with the portfolio holder.
That reflects the seepage on the sow of Springwood.
When, remind me, when's the sale expected?
Cllr Michael Owen - 0:10:03
And then is it worth us giving like a permanent interest
holiday to, to Qualis to try and get them back on track?
Like I deal a lot in leverage finance.
These are called PIC loans, payment in kind loans,
where you just back end all the interest exchange on a loan.
We could do something like that with Qualis to try and give
them some headroom, although it creates some problem
in a snowball of debt, but yeah.
Owen Sparks - 0:10:29
So we're expecting the completion to happen within the next quarter, so before the next
loan payment is due.
Obviously that will give sufficient cash for that to the obligations we paid off.
We are looking at different ways of structuring from the debts moving forward and that will
form part of the report we bring in in December.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:10:50
So the expectation is that when Springwood Grove is sold,
Qualis will make both the outstanding debt payment and its new debt payment
and additional debt payments because it's no longer paying for it
or that it will continue paying for the loans on the original schedule?
Owen Sparks - 0:11:12
We're still discussing really to make sure the cash flow is sustainable over medium terms
if we're being mixture of both.
Okay, that's helpful.
Anyone else?
Is Councillor Owen?
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:11:21
Cllr Michael Owen - 0:11:23
I mean, yeah, the Council's got a bit of a problem unless we go to unitary and somehow
this all gets sorted out, but we have debt that's going to be going up to like probably
5%.
We can only raise the Council tax two, three, whatever it is.
this is just a horrendous situation
where one side of the balance sheet
is gonna continue going up and the other can't keep pace.
We need to find something like a Google land sale
or something and start paying down the debt
because it's just not sustainable, right?
It is a real long -term problem if we can't sort this out.
Yeah.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:11:55
So just from the debt perspective,
Owen Sparks - 0:11:58
what we do is obviously we profile our loans
from sort of one to 50 years.
So it's when, obviously, we have to refinance debt
that that increase in debt cost hits us.
Obviously our average loan cost at the moment
is three and a half percent,
which is obviously lower than the market at the moment.
So really something to keep an eye on over a period of time
to try and manage our debt exposure.
We do expect its interest rates to come up
and down over the horizon,
but obviously not to come down any time soon.
So it is an ongoing issue for us.
And yes, a big capital state would be Johnny Hante.
I mean, there's an issue, though, isn't there?
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:12:40
Because there's already asset sales that Qualis is going to make,
which are delayed and presumably comes to a point where
disposing of assets,
you know, which are so far undervalued,
is sort of not worthwhile if the property market's not in a good position,
even if it is, you know, costing money, money and interim.
anything that's supposed to be in the fire cell,
you're not gonna get good value for.
Yeah, sorry.
So we do look with our treasury advisors
Owen Sparks - 0:13:13
at the most appropriate borrowing strategy,
looking at longer term as far as we can,
the profile of debt and the length of debt borrowing as well
and we do on a regular basis look at disposal of assets
and whether that's appropriate or not,
bearing in mind capital values and income that we generate for revenue as well.
So again, that's always a balanced view, but we look at that on a regular basis.
Okay. Members, any other questions on the Treasury Management Strategy?
Councillor Noyes.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:13:43
I just had a couple of questions.
Cllr Martin Morris - 0:13:46
On the PWLB borrowing, I mean, there's some tables here that tell us that it's, as you say,
It's the weighted average rate for the interest on that,
is about 3 .5%.
And there's also a table that tells us the maturity of the debt.
About 2 % is going to be rolled over within the next 12 months,
according to that table.
I mean, do you know, do we have an estimate
about what the impact is going to be?
Like, what rates we will get on that?
Will we take fixed or floating?
And how will it affect our finances when that rolls over?
Also, you could look at the ESO one to two years and all those other bands that are more
interested in the short -term impact of the rise in interest rates.
Owen Sparks - 0:14:33
As part of our MCHFP development, we look at our loans in detail over a five -year period
and we make estimates around how much that refinancing will cost, again with our Treasury
so we know roughly what that interest obligation will be.
We make sure we build that into our revenue budget as well.
So we've got that covered.
And that's quite a large chunk of some of our revenue costs
that we reflect, but we view that
in days of a five year basis.
In the H -road it's slightly different.
We make some long term assumptions,
but obviously when you're going out over a number of years,
it gets more and more difficult to do.
So we do that as part of the revenue capture budgets which we look at together.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:15:21
Cllr Martin Morris - 0:15:23
I did have a follow -up question about the loans that we have for Quarris and the repayments.
It does say in here somewhere that it's going to be deferred waiting for the completion
of Springwood Grove.
And I mean, okay, so what's the timing on this?
I mean, when do we expect Springwood Grove to be finished?
how much are they going to repay and what will remain once they've repaid it?
And do we expect any further repayment?
Where are we with realising Qols assets
and how much are we going to get repaid?
Because that would give us a clear idea of where we're going to stand with our unsecured debt.
Owen Sparks - 0:16:05
So what we are doing, we are reviewing the outstanding commercial projects on a regular
basis.
We are expecting Springwood to be complete over the next couple of weeks and then obviously
that sale will go forward.
Is that the last one?
So that there'll be no more asset sales from Qualis?
So Qualis own St. John's and Hemnall.
So it was one of the initial asset purchases around Qualis.
So they're the two ones that are remaining.
Obviously they haven't got developments
on their distal sites at the moment.
Obviously they'll have a glitter centre.
Is there any plan to dispose of those sites?
Cllr Martin Morris - 0:16:49
Or what's going to happen to them?
I mean, at some point we want to monetize those assets,
won't we?
There are options being looked at and there have been some plans that have been put forward before,
Owen Sparks - 0:16:59
but again we're looking at what's most appropriate in the current market, the current situation, to
really make sure we get the best value from those assets as we can going forward.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:17:13
If you look at the cabinet reports from QALIS, they go through site by site on the plans for
some of these and you'll get some more detail in that if you want to take a look.
Has to do with a bit more detail here.
Cllr Michael Owen - 0:17:26
Owen Sparks - 0:17:42
I think that's a good point.
be but there's obviously premiums, discounts, whatever we want to do.
So again, it's just looking around what's most appropriate.
Any other members or non -members?
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:18:01
Councillor George.
Hi, good evening.
Cllr Mandy George - 0:18:06
I do have quite a few questions but I'll stick to a couple.
First of all, given the security for the 30 million Qolis commercial loan, it's now valid
at 22 .62 million, that's a 7 .38 million drop in outstanding debt.
What chance can you give us, Owen, that the council can recover that full £30 million
debt if Qolis has even more financial difficulties?
So can you answer that one or should I ask both at the same time?
If it's only one on the commercial debt, let's deal with that one first, because that also
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:18:44
fills in the five -year threshold that you're talking about in terms of loans coming up
refinancing, doesn't it?
Owen Sparks - 0:18:51
So obviously the commercial assets are worth less than the loans that are paid for at the
moment.
So that's the underlying security of those loans, there is a shortfall.
Obviously from the council perspective, we are getting that revenue stream coming through.
We're not looking to sell those assets at the moment and this situation changes.
So at that point that loan won't, that reduction value won't crystallise.
So it's not a cost that we need to obviously be mindful of from an NGP perspective's
time, because that written new cost is still coming in and supports that loan from the
leases and the assets.
Okay, Kat.
Cllr Mandy George - 0:19:33
My second one is, now, how much of the Council's annual revenue budget depends on commercial
property income and QALYST interest in repayments and what would be the financial impact if
commercial property income fell by 10 % and QALYST failed to meet its scheduled payments?
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:19:54
Do you mean commercial property as in the commercial property managed by QALYST or commercial
property as in the commercial, the out of area?
There's two sides to both if you like, one and the other.
Okay, so thanks.
I couldn't answer offhand without looking into it.
Owen Sparks - 0:20:09
Follow it afterwards.
Yes, so how would that be followed up?
Cllr Mandy George - 0:20:16
It's all maxed out a bit.
I can follow it up to the mitts.
Owen Sparks - 0:20:21
Anything else from...
Councillor Callaghan.
Yeah, sorry, you've been bombarded here with quality questions.
Cllr Paul Kelleher - 0:20:29
How are you, perhaps?
We've probably gone over a few of these bits,
But just because I get asked these questions by residents, and I need to sort of ask questions,
but we've got 30 million commercial loan outs down to the quality, so it's meant to be repaid
by 2030?
Is that right?
Is that going to be repaid by 2030?
Sorry, I might have missed a bit of that in the context.
Or is it not?
Or how does it work, basically?
Owen Sparks - 0:21:01
So it won't be repaid unless the market changes and it's appropriate to dispose of the assets.
So what it's like, it'd happen again, but when we get close to the time, we'll look
at it, whether that loan gets refinanced, replaced.
Councillor Moyes.
Cllr Martin Morris - 0:21:16
So when you say refinanced, you're just going to roll it over on the PWB, I guess.
PWLB, yeah, so you'll just take it.
Okay, so that entirely depends on what rates are prevalent at the time, which would be
2030, basically.
So there's a significant amount of interest rates and risk in all this rolling over, as
That's normal what we normally do with most of our loans.
We basically do refinance them.
That tends to happen.
Owen Sparks - 0:21:39
And you remember we had that minimum revenue provision that we make in revenue.
So that generally is sort of part paying back the loans.
So it depends how much cash we've got at the time, how we manage it.
But obviously we're always subject to that interest rate risk, which is a significant
risk to Council.
And obviously it's one of the things we monitor, one of the reasons we have these reports quarterly.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:22:04
And I suppose it's implicit, but perhaps we need to make it explicit, the rental
income we get from those properties covers the interest costs, and then there's a cushion
on top, one assumes.
Okay, thanks.
Can I have a follow -up question?
Yeah.
Cllr Martin Morris - 0:22:23
So the interest rate risk is expressed how?
Just in a single figure?
I'm not quite sure how you define interest rate risk.
Owen Sparks - 0:22:34
So what we do as part of the median term for an actual plan and the budget as a whole,
I do something called Section 25 statement, and that sets out a whole range of risks,
inflation, interest rate, increase in demand for services, homelessness.
And what we do, we look at the underlying to the council.
We also do some sort of sensitivity analysis to see what might happen if interest rates
go up by 1%, inflation down by 1%, that sort of thing.
And then that helps us form a view of our financial stability and our reserves position,
and that's how we manage it.
So we manage it in the round, but looking at significant, specific variables and how
they might behave in different scenarios.
And that's really how the council manages its financial risk in the round.
And who decides on what the scenarios are?
Cllr Martin Morris - 0:23:25
So I mean, obviously these scenarios are quite important to the outcome as to what you estimate
to be the likely shift in say interest rates or inflation.
Who gets to decide that and how is it defined?
It's not defined specifically.
So I will do that sensitive analysis.
It's my sensitive analysis statement and obviously members will make sure they come for that
sufficient as part of their approval of the budget.
that's out clearly in the budget reports
and members will consider that.
Councillor Ingrid.
So we do like sensitivity analysis,
which will show like a 1 % increase in rates,
Cllr Michael Owen - 0:24:02
what it does to our finances and stuff.
We don't actually run much rate risk with,
when we have assets that generate income,
because in theory they should offset a lot of it.
Where we have problems is on debt
that isn't income generating, right?
So QALYST ironically probably isn't much
of a rate risk problem for us,
if the assets perform.
It's actually the other stuff on the balance sheet that can be a problem.
Yeah. And historically, of course, some of this arises from the fact
that Qualis actually took on the debt
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:24:29
a long way before it
ended up with assets.
So a lot of companies, you know, if we've seen with the asset disposals,
will actually look to do a land purchase or take on debt once
once the planning commission is granted or whatever,
I mean, QALYST took on the land and the debt
well in advance of getting planning permission or anything.
So it's sort of, it's got the overhang of debt
from early years, even some income generating stuff,
hasn't it, yeah.
I think back to Councillor Owen's point as well,
of the lot of the council's debt in these figures
Owen Sparks - 0:25:12
in relation to the HRI as well,
Again, that's underpinned by the council has values and income streams that flow from that,
although that is up in the fence, but a lot of those headline figures is made up of HRA debt.
Okay, anything else on the Treasury Management Report?
As Mr Price just said, it's not just about QALYST.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:25:33
There's the bit of general fund borrowing and quite a lot of HRA borrowing as well.
Okay, so we're asked to note that.
Sorry, was that a hand up?
No, it wasn't.
I thought I saw you move out the corner of my eye.
So we can move on to the internal audit monitoring report, which starts at page 32.

8 Internal Audit Monitoring Report

Who is going to take this one?
Ms March.
Sarah Marsh - 0:26:04
Thank you, Chair.
So this gives you an update on the work of internal audits since our last meeting.
I'm not quite aware of what we'd like to be with the audit plan, so I informed the committee
last time that we had some long -term sickness within the team.
That has continued throughout the quarter, but everyone is now back at work, so that's
really good news.
So we can do some catch -up.
I've reprioritised the audits so that the more riskier ones have been done first, and
And also we found additional resources, so we've brought in some external help to help
deliver that plan.
We have, we're reporting one final report.
This is the housing health and safety one substantial assurance, which is the highest
level that we can give.
And this is around the big six, so things like gas safety, water, fire risk assessments,
asbestos and things like that.
And it was really interesting audit
because we did it previously about two years ago
when they just brought in their C365 systems
to monitor their compliance.
And we found those data sets weren't quite all aligned.
And when we did the audit this time, it was really good.
It was very structured.
The system was working really well
and the performance coming out of it,
we could rely on the integrity of the data there.
Moving on then to the recommendation tracker.
So we still got low numbers there.
We got five outstanding.
The one high priority one is around the commercial rents
and there's been a heck of a lot of work going on
in the background to make sure that that is being addressed.
And the other ones, we don't have any particular concerns
to bring to your attention as a committee.
When I give my annual opinion on governance,
internal controls and risk management,
I don't rely just solely on the work of the audits that we do.
We do a lot of work in the background,
working with the organisation,
so I can understand what's going on.
In particular, we're doing a series of fraud risk assessments
across the council, and that's helping ensure
that we're compliant with the Economic Crime
and Corporate Transparency Act.
We attended the Project Management Essentials workshop.
That was a really good workshop.
There was a lot of people there.
So, because we audit projects,
so it's good to understand how that system
works within this particular council.
We've also done some risk workshops,
which we find is really good,
because we're getting to understand,
getting to the nitty -gritty of risks that are happening.
And we've helped the finance team
re -look and re -evaluate their risks.
And also this week we've been working with the
information management group as well to look at their risks.
Terra Verde approached internal audit and asked
for an expert view on their procurement rules and
finance scheme of delegations.
So I was really pleased that they reached out to us.
We don't have to do that.
That's not part of my remit, but it's really good
that they're interacting with internal audit.
Moving down the report, top of page 34,
is around the work of the corporate fraud team.
There's good successes with the right to buys there.
And I'm really pleased that we finally,
through the corporate fraud team and the work of internal audit,
got the council to launch a new process for declarations of interest.
It's all done through our HR system, and it's all automated and electronic.
people have to complete that
by the end of October
because this is the first chance of it happening
and those who have not completed
will be following up on them
and there will be an annual process going forward.
Lastly,
on section 12 there,
the corporate team
is not just around housing and things like that,
they have worked hard
with the private sector housing team
and has managed to, through the work,
ensure that we've got £36 ,000 back to the Council.
The last part of the report is an update
on the annual governance statement.
The first one there is local government reorganisation,
and as you know, that's been paused for the moment,
but we're making good progress on the rest of them.
Thank you.
Thanks very much.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:30:45
We are lots there in different areas.
Members, any questions?
Councillor Keller.
Cllr Paul Kelleher - 0:30:55
Sorry, I note you mentioned about the 36 ,000 recovered, which is good news.
Given that successful recovery from that landlord, are we proactively identifying other landlords
operating unlicensed HMOs rather than relying solely on complaints or referrals?
Sarah Marsh - 0:31:15
I can't answer on behalf of that department.
I'm just reporting on the work that the corporate fraud team did with them.
Perhaps that's a question we can follow up.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:31:28
So I was going to ask, is that, how do we find that out?
Is it for next time kind of thing or?
Cllr Paul Kelleher - 0:31:34
Sarah Marsh - 0:31:39
I will find out for you and it will either be an email or we will put it in the minutes.
Okay.
Casimoyce?
Cllr Martin Morris - 0:31:47
I know the government has not been that helpful with LGR, given that they suddenly decided
to stop the process, but it has now restarted and the target is 2029, which is not very
far away.
I know it is all very uncertain, but is there anything that we are doing to try and anticipate
what might happen.
I mean, I know we did a lot of work based on the outcome of five.
I mean, is there any sort of preliminary work we can do to be in a better position when
the government issues its minded to decision on Essex?
Who's this?
Mr Sparks.
Owen Sparks - 0:32:28
So, I think conversations are happening with chief execs and leaders just to really understand
what might happen, how it might be reinvigorated.
I think from current positions, we do wait and hear,
hopefully read this soon,
what those new configurations will be,
because they do have a big impact on where we're at.
Members will remember that when our activity were paused,
we did sort of a managed pause part of the activity today,
so that it's ready to be rolled out again.
So we're ready to go, but it will depend quite a lot on what those configurations are, if
they change or not really, and how that might be structured.
So yes, but with a mind, there's still lots of uncertainty.
We need to make sure we don't waste effort, but we're just sort of ready to go again,
those conversations started.
Cllr Martin Morris - 0:33:20
Yeah, so I mean, I guess the government's minded -to decision won't introduce anything
new, will it?
It'll be based on the options that have already been put forward.
So you don't have like an infinite number of possibilities to take into account.
I just wondered if there was any focus within that on particular solutions.
Owen Sparks - 0:33:41
Yeah, the government isn't asking for new configurations to be submitted.
They do reserve the right to change and amend what has been submitted.
So again, we are sort of working towards it, but we're not jumping in or wasting lots of
at this point in time.
So we might have just been doing plenty of work
without waste source resources
not gonna bear fruit going forward.
Okay, thank you.
Any other members or non -members?
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:34:09
Okay, I mean, you mentioned,
I'm obviously pleased to hear that the sickness problem
is no longer an issue.
but you've still got 80 % of the audits to carry out in 40 % of the year.
You talked about prioritising.
Do you think you'll get through the work plan
or are we likely to be rolling things over again?
So my audit plan is always an ambitious one.
I like to do as much as possible.
I need to ensure there's enough work
so I can give my annual conclusion at the end of the year
on internal controls, risk management.
and governance, I just don't remember what I'm meant to be doing.
And so, ideally, I would like to complete the plan, but that isn't going to happen.
So towards the end of the financial year, I'll be coming to you with ones that I want
to maybe defer or stop doing because we're starting our audit planning.
It's very much based on the risks of the council and that's just changing all the time.
So, and just to reiterate, it's not just about the audits.
My conclusion is based on all the work that we do
in our interactions with the council.
So I'm confident I would have done enough
to give my conclusion, but not enough to,
we won't be able to do all the audits.
No, okay, thanks.
I mean, you had just written a point in that,
quite a lot of the outstanding audits are directly linked
to some of the high priority issues
and the risk for disjoint may,
and I think we're all conscious of that.
Right, are we happy to note the internal audit report
and the government statement update?
Which brings us on to the risk register,

9 Risk Management

which we are asked to consider
and then make any recommendations to Cabinet.
Mr Sparks?
This report presents the October update on the corporate risk register.
Owen Sparks - 0:36:22
Again, you'll be used to the format and the approach.
Most of the scores remain unchanged since last year, again, reflecting their strategic nature.
There are two key movements to bring to the witness attention.
Firstly, the quality of major planning risk has been reduced from 20 to 16.
That reflects that we've had two quarters below the 10 % maximum.
Obviously the council is still in designation and that could change if obviously we're losing
people going forward so it's still at high risk but we've reduced it really to reflect
that we've had that two quarters now, that 10 % threshold.
Secondly, the future proof in the workforce risk has been closed as a corporate risk and
we've managed at service level.
This reflects really the workforce plan, the ongoing refresh of the people strategy.
A lot of the work we're doing is now with BAU,
which we've spoken about before,
succession planning, single points of contact,
which again, services are managed at a local level.
All the other scores remain unchanged,
and that includes some of the high risk scores previously,
around homelessness and the sub -security
that we've spoken about before,
and especially that five year housing land supply
that we added last quarter, I think.
I think again that remains at 20 because obviously we haven't got that five year land supply.
And we need to see if there's a report with somebody next.
Okay, thanks very much.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:37:56
BAU business as usual, just in case anyone was wondering.
Councillor Owen.
Cllr Michael Owen - 0:38:03
Yeah, I don't normally love this one because it's not really my wheelhouse, but every now and then I have a pick at it.
But FIN 001 and FIN 002 are both, sorry, one is 10, one is 12.
I think delivering a balanced budget, I would say, is probably much higher risk than a 10.
I would say the financial viability of QALYST is debatable, whether it's a 12 or higher,
but I would probably say those two need to be questioned.
And then recently the government announced, you know, we should all have three days worth
of water and food in case, I'm trying not to swear here, but in case something hits
the fan.
But I think, should we not put this down as a risk?
because we have a big stock of council houses, we have vulnerable people in those council houses.
What is the council's, what are we going to do if something really bad happened and people didn't
have food and water for three days? Maybe things like the food banks can't open in their usual
venues, so do we try and do something in our venues or, you know, I just think there's a lot
to be, it's a huge area of work, but I think if something really did happen, it feels like we're
not prepared for it because it's not even an item on our risk register. Thank you.
OK, interesting. Important to note the risk scores
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:39:12
and the residual risk after mitigation, not the scores before mitigation.
Who wants to pick up the emergency planning, Ms Marks?
Owen Sparks - 0:39:23
I think there's lots to that, isn't there, really, in a nutshell.
I suppose it's sort of linked a little bit to the cyber security risk,
which obviously we've got at quite a high level,
a little bit to the community cohesion risks that we've spoken about previously
that obviously was elevated and was removed.
I think a lot of, we've had some issues,
haven't been able to be aware of,
with Thames Water recently as well.
And obviously the council I think has responded to that
to support the community where that's needed.
So I think it's probably worth something
we can take away and think about,
but I think it touches lots of different things
that I think we've got avenues into,
but I appreciate we haven't got that cohesively pulled together specific thing.
But I think we could probably, the risk we've got, cover some of the eventualities
and some of the way we respond to it.
But I think we definitely haven't got that as a cohesive
eventuality that I think we could probably look at specifically.
And one assumes and hopes that in the housing services
service of a risk register, there is a risk there, which is, you know, what if,
services to tenants go away or what if the particularly the care homes but you know that's
a good question to ask and something we can ask you know to be checked and and flagged up to cabinet
and to cover and as you say we're not just responsible directly for the properties that
we own but there's wider you know community implications that you know as a sort of
Yeah, the voice chair.
Thank you.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:41:11
Sissel Heiberg - 0:41:13
My comment is perhaps a little bit higher level, not in the weeds as such, but you've
got quite a few high residual risk points here that you're wanting input on.
You say very clearly that you're wanting cabinet to approve, and then you outline completeness
of the risk register, accuracy of the risk scoring.
I wonder if what you're really wanting to get approval on is risk acceptance for some
of those high -rated items, so perhaps you want to be a bit more explicit about that
ask?
Owen Sparks - 0:41:48
I think that's a very good question about risk appetite that the councils will need
to accept.
I think that's something we may want to do at some point as an exercise by the council
about where we are comfortable.
I think that this recognises that,
I think cybersecurity is a good example, isn't it,
that we're never going to get that down to a level
that we'd all be comfortable with,
because it's just changed all the time.
But I think where we are, we have got those mitigations
in place and we've got the further work going forward.
So I think if there's specific risks
that this committee feels they wouldn't be comfortable with,
I think it would be helpful for you to play that up,
because we can then go and look at that.
I think you're right, I think that general risk appetite against various sorts of risks,
whether that's financial, whether that's cybersecurity, health and safety risks, is
something we can perhaps look at in the future.
Councillor Boyce.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:42:47
Oh yeah, I do have a couple of questions.
Cllr Martin Morris - 0:42:52
What coming back on contingency plans, I mean, do we have a clear view of what contingency
plans we should have?
I mean, we've got a whole range of things that could go wrong.
We can't have contingency plans for everything.
But do we have a clear idea of what we should be planning for as a contingency and therefore
a way of making sure that those plans are concrete and realisable?
Shall I just ask my questions?
Well, if you're the other secretary, let's answer that one first.
I mean, the council has got a part -time emergency planning officer, hasn't it?
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:43:32
Sarah Marsh - 0:43:34
So we've recently done the business continuity audit and we found that we do have an overall
corporate business continuity plan and then we've got the individual service ones.
And what the council has done, they've done two exercises now, tabletop exercises, to
make sure that they actually work.
On the IT side, we do the penetration testing and we have the IT disaster recovery plan
as well.
And then to do with emergency planning, which is the wider community, again, we have a plan
in place for that.
So we have lots of plans and we do test them as we go along.
My other question is related to cyber security, which is on here.
Cllr Martin Morris - 0:44:16
There has been a big uptick recently in successful attacks on websites and so on.
We saw a global issue with some of the protocols that are used on websites which brought lots
of websites down.
I think AI is enabling these attacks to happen much more quickly and be much more effective.
I wondered, we have got cyber security at 16 after mitigations, but I feel that the
recent change in the speed and accuracy of some of these attacks means that we need to
reconsider whether we are fully managing this risk in the way we should.
Sarah Marsh - 0:45:06
So we've actually just completed the cybersecurity audit.
We've given it reasonable assurance.
There's a couple of areas that just need a bit of tightening up, but we have everything
in place that we ran the firewalls and access staff staff are weakest point and we have
phishing attacks and also training and awareness.
So I get your point that it seems to be getting worse,
but we haven't touched wood.
You know, we're under attack all the time,
but there's none of them being successful.
And as Owen had said, is that, you know,
we could never be able to reduce that risk,
but we keep a very active eye on it throughout every day.
This is Fox.
Owen Sparks - 0:45:58
So I think on the other side of that, the other point, again, we are going to be able
to take it, an AI audit and the governments around that as well, again, to make sure we've
got those guard routes in place for our use of artificial intelligence, you know, different
sides of that one to make sure that none of our data is obviously getting out, also to
make sure as far as we can that it's, all the doors are closed, so again, other people
can't come in as well.
But we have a whole range of substitution activity.
We've spoken about the penetration testing,
cath testing, cyber assurance, framework.
We do that as well to make sure, again,
we've got all the processes in place we can possibly have.
It is an ever -changing environment,
and that does evolve pretty much on a weekly basis.
So again, it's making sure the team is on top of that.
Best practise, best we can.
So that's an ongoing activity for the IT team,
working across the whole council as well to make sure everyone's aware of responsibilities.
As we said, we get out disguised, phishing emails, a whole range of things we do.
It's worth noting, I think, there's a direct attack on the council.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:47:04
It can be an attack on the council suppliers or a bit of tech the council uses or something
like that, because we had the PHP thing recently, didn't we, and the council's forms had to
be taken offline for a while, and some organisations sort of patched it very quickly and left them
running very quickly.
others took ages. I'm not quite sure where the council fitted in that sort of spectrum,
but it was quite a, it made it very real, I think, in terms of sort of directly affecting
the council and affecting residents. I mean, what was the sort of learning from that in
terms of how we felt the council dealt with it?
Owen Sparks - 0:47:38
I think, for a council perspective, I think our systems were quite robust. We were relying
on some of our suppliers to do appropriate patches
before we could bring them back again.
So again, it's not all under Council control.
It's suppliers that needed to react to that
before we could bring them back on board again.
So it's again, making sure we're in touch
with our suppliers to make sure we're aware
of what needs to happen.
What we have got, we have a database really
that flags up where there are security issues,
we're aware of from some of our other systems.
But obviously, again, it's a changing process, but we're just on top of it as we can be.
So from a council perspective, I think it went reasonably well.
Do we know how long the forms were down, that it was down for?
I don't think the website went down.
A couple of our internal systems were down for a few days.
Right.
Okay.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:48:28
I wanted to come back to actually the vice chair's point about risk.
I mean, so much depends on, you know,
the bit of the report which talks about
further actions required, doesn't it?
And actually being sure those further actions
are being implemented and happening and going.
And it's, you know, some have got deadlines
and some are ongoing.
And I think we need to sort of be aware that,
that's where the impact on the scores happens
and that's our confidence on those things happening.
The other thing I wanted to mention was,
I mean, we expressed the risk
of the continued financial viability of QALYIS
and the narrative there,
It talks about whether or not it will be financially viable.
And again, I think that's a risk that's crystallised,
hasn't it?
We know that the debts outweigh the assets
and I do wonder whether that wording needs to be updated
to reflect the current position
and the sort of actions you were talking about earlier
in order to deal with them.
I think that risk has changed.
Owen Sparks - 0:49:59
I think it's now ensuring we've got obviously appropriate governance in place and appropriate
provision and they're obviously monitoring that just on an ongoing basis to make sure
that remains appropriate.
So it's not that there won't be a risk for precisely, it's making sure we're managing
it appropriately and we've got proper provisions in place for it.
Cllr Jon Whitehouse - 0:50:19
Yeah, yeah, and I think, yeah, it's, I mean, the risk register is not just about the financial
risks to the council, so organisational risks
across the board and about how they're being dealt with,
as we said, about the residual risk.
Anything else before we move on?
So if you can flag up to Cabinet the issue about the,
or you'll find some words for it.
I've got to say the three days tins,
but the basic sort of emergency resilience side of things.
and updating the quality of risk
to reflect the current situation.
And did you want to include something about risk appetite
and being explicit that for some things
we're happier to accept a higher risk than other things?
Okay.
Right.
And members happy with those points going to cabinet?
Thanks very much.
Well, that brings us on 20 hours of business.
Is there any other business?

10 Any Other Business

11 Exclusion of Public and Press

Okay, and there's no items to exclude the press and public.
So thank you very much for attending.
Thanks for everyone's questions and comments and answers.
And there's a couple of things that came up.
We'll try and follow up with the appropriate officers.
Thanks very much everyone.
District councillor for Epping West and Rural ward
Liberal Democrats
Co-optee - Audit & Governance Committee
District councillor for Waltham Abbey North ward
Reform UK
Democratic Services Officer
Epping Forest District Council
Chief Internal Auditor
Epping Forest District Council
District councillor for Waltham Abbey North ward
Labour Party
District councillor for Loughton Forest ward
Loughton Residents Association
Interim Strategic Director / S151 Officer
Epping Forest District Council
District councillor for Epping East ward
Liberal Democrats